My head is still spinning from visiting a China so different from everything I was taught. So, I continue to process on multiple layers. This week I have been pondering a possibility that the Communists/Socialists have already learned a lesson we are still struggling to master.
I am pondering it partially because of the extreme anger expressed by the polarized camps over proposed changes in American health care. It occurs to me, that we are struggling with something bigger than medical care and costs. Costs certainly do not seem to matter when we choose to destroy people we consider “other.” I think the real issue just may be the tyranny of grand designs.
Both China and the Soviet Union have already spread power out from one center of control to many localities. They were in many ways more modern than us in their years of building. Their true believers thought it was possible to design one system which would work for all people. They fought for it, killed for it, sacrificed rights for it, and it did not work. I believe they are ahead of us in the move past it to understanding that man is incapable of creating grand designs that fit all people.
I think our love of individualism and emphasis on individual accomplishment within our system may have blinded us to this same lesson. We are still arguing about which political party is best suited to creating the country that works for us all. I think we should look East. The giant empires are spreading power to smaller units for local control. There is no longer a faith in human capacity to create plans from the center of power which will work for everyone. We cry out repeatedly that we do not want Washington controlling our lives and choices! When will we actually listen to ourselves and believe what we are saying? Creating the one right answer is a task beyond the capacity of man.
Praise God, it was never given to us to do in the first place. I am not completely post-modern. I think the Communists still miss the essential fact. There is One Who Is. There is a Grand Plan which came into being by the first Word of Being. The Tao, the Logos, the Word made Flesh contains all the plan the world needs. We are not capable. He is. (It’s God’s name after all!)
I hope we learn the lesson before we return to the methods of violence so common to man’s past when any group feels pressed too far, or becomes true believers that their philosophy will be best for all once the opposition is silenced. The debate was clear and loud at the original US Constitutional Convention — should power be centralized or widely dispersed in the States? After 200+ years of experimenting, the anger tells me we are not happy with master plans, systems of public welfare, collection and dispersal of taxes, or control of our basic life needs under the control of any far removed representatives.
Perhaps it is time, with faith in a Loving, All Knowing, Victorious God the communists do not know, to follow their lead on human systems and quit trying to build planetary houses of cards. Perhaps it is time for power and control to be more widely spread, more available to the people who pay for them and depend upon them. Maybe Washington is never going to be Jerusalem (History clearly shows that there have been people who thought otherwise.) The Communists are copying us in trying to substitute the God of money even as they break apart the central powers. We know that path is folly as well. There is no grand human plan that will save us.
Where should power reside? How about a manger, a carpenter’s house, an oppressed countryside, a cross, and in glorious mystery both seated in Heaven and enthroned in human hearts? May we realize again that the power that will decide our fates is unmoved by human whims, votes, Supreme Courts, legislatures, Presidents, Dictators, and tyrants. The eternal comes as a small child and is still moved by the genuine prayers of a single small child, not decrees of state.
If anybody read all that, thanks for musing with me. I think we are witnessing the end of the man’s worship of large scale human solutions. I hope we do not damage each other too much in the process. I’ll be here with the Babe who made all, sustains all, and completes all.
peace