don’t ask me how my mind is contemplating theology right now, as I begin writing I do not know.
But, this idea is rolling around, growing, and begs to be expressed. I have always had problems with American Calvinist versions of election and damnation, even when they are billed as free will. The idea that God will save those who hear and are able to respond to the message, does not seem much different from the hard core teachings of His only choosing a few elect anyway. I have written about it here before.
But in the past, I have always seen it presented as a driving force for evangelism and mission — got to go to those millions God is going to damn if we don’t get somebody there to tell them! What is dawning on me now is how it works in the opposite direction. I believe its underlying message is actually anti-evangelism as in the original American churches, but more subtly.
I know my church history well enough to know that the old order American Calvinists believed in proving your election, not evangelization. What I am contemplating now is a similar effect among folks who believe they are evangelicals.
Does a belief that God is willing to damn millions who never hear lead to a belief that we — white, northern, western, literate, wealthy — have a special claim on the call? Does it lead to a subtle way of neglecting our neighbor who has so many chances to join us in church? If God will condemn those who never hear, why should we make extra effort to reach out to those who do not come to us? Again, I am not talking about anything we would verbalize. I am talking about subconscious justifications of neglecting our brothers and sisters.
Let me push it past “four laws,” does it subtly let us have hard hearts toward those who live in poverty, who are without political voice, who are left behind no matter how much propaganda we hear? If we believe that God is willing to send millions blindly off to hell, does that allow us the subtle out we need to ignore their hell which is now?
Ahh, there is the connection. Will you ignore me and my suffering loved one if you decide decide we are not like you? Will you condemn us? Does the prevalent theology of the American church invite you to look the other way, just like your uncaring god?
peace