If I have a student who wants to learn, who is willing to do the work I give, who listens to the corrections I offer — and then at the end of our time gets a failing grade from me, who failed?
Did they fail as a student? Or did I feel as their teacher, leader, mentor, friend, and guide?
Me.
It is plain, simple, obvious, and inescapable. When they are placed under my care wanting to learn and I do not teach, I have failed them. If they do not care, are already defeated as a child, are afraid to risk new challenge and growth and I do not re-inspire them, I fail to live out my calling. They are required to show up bringing who they are. I am there representing the God of all power and love and it is my responsibility to love courage and strength back into the reluctant, to design experiences that teach what they are to learn, and to offer opportunities to demonstrate mastery of knowledge which fit the learner and the content of the lessons. I stand before the throne bathed in mercy and seek new wisdom for the next round, the next students, the next subject. But, I stand before God knowing each one is entrusted to my care for a season and that God cares very much about seeing the best happen for the “least” of them.
But, I do not see it happening in church.
I have seen us use people up, chew them to pieces, cast them aside and expect them to be grateful for the experience. If years of sitting under sermons, lessons and trainings leaves people unchanged, deemed unworthy of service, or unfazed at our holiness and spiritual guidance, then the failure must be theirs. They have sin in their lives, unrepentant lifestyles, spiritual barriers, or defiant hearts. Heaven forbid they should have the nerve to become ill and fail to respond to our faith filled prayers for healing! God forbid that should tell the truth that they are seeking something deeper than we ourselves know, have pains we do not even want to hear of, or are open enough to consider Truth beyond our walls. We have the Truth, the power, and the saving doctrine. And it is; well to be Biblical, it is a pile of dung — stinking, rotten, nauseating dung.
I watch a supposed pastor have people under their leadership, training, and care for years with true hearts of love and service to God, and at the end of it hear only belittling and dismissive words from this supposed shepherd, and I want to vomit. I have no softer words. I am no longer capable of pleasantries in the presence of it. The situation that prompted this purging, the neglect of a departing servant was only reported to me, I was not involved, it had nothing to do with me. But I know the territory, the pain, and the damage and I want to go as postal as an Old Testament prophet or Jesus of Nazareth with a whip. It is wrong.
I cannot participate in a system that allows the pampered stateside worker with the decorated air conditioned office to oversee a budget of 6 or 7 figures while requiring field workers to raise their own salaries, refuse to train those who deeply desire to serve God, act in belittling and dismissive ways towards those of his own flock who are going to serve while praising his self chosen few. I cannot participate in a place that claims to represent the God of all love and treats people in ways which deny them both just treatment and the power to speak the truth about themselves, their treatment at the hands of the organization, and the real personal and spiritual damage that has been done to them. I cannot give material or spiritual support to an organization which cannot separate the Sustainer of the universe from their own cultural gods of business, power, politics, and warfare.
I am the failed student. No, make that the expelled student! I understand them. I honor their honest fury. I can no longer even entertain the idea of behaving as if you make sense while you heap dung on the heads of those who seek the Lord.
If a student of mine ever left with those words, I would be before the throne dissolved before my Lord and King. I would kneel before the Presence knowing I had failed in my responsibilities and use of my gifts. I would beg for the courage to go on, to seek healing, to renew the one I failed. If anyone from my old church reads this they will shrug me off as a sore-headed, self centered, ungovernable maverick with questionable theology.
Go with your gods then.
I go with mine and I am content.
And I pray for you if the day ever comes that you see beyond your ego into the eyes of the One who made, loves, and follows after every one you have failed to love and nurture. Keep worshiping yourselves. I tried to come back to be with dear friends in the membership and on the staff.
I can grant you your humanity as I expect you to admit mine.
But, I cannot sit silently in the presence of the hubris that allows you to dare to speak your opinions, ideas, and prejudices as the will and Word of God. If I am present, I will have to rebuke you. If I thought there was a shred of a chance of being heard, I would risk your anger and your wounds for the sake of both our souls. But, I see no ears that hear and I will not sow discord in the body even if the body is cancer riddled and abusive. I leave you to it. May God have mercy on our souls.
peace,
really; through all my disappointment, human frailty and disgust, I send you peace.
Just stay away from me.